Every year, our Seven Steps creator and CEO Jen McVeity sits the NAPLAN writing test – in pretty much the same conditions Australian students face. And every year she finds it hard.
As an author, it’s obviously not the actual writing that’s a challenge. In fact, Jen feels that the NAP Marking Criteria truly values great writing.
But it’s the limitations put on the test taker that are the problem.
This year, Jen tackled the Years 7/9 NAPLAN Persuasive test. You can check out Jen’s written response to the 2018 topic ‘New Technology’, the marks she received from a trained NAPLAN marker and Jen’s debrief from her results here. [Members’ Exclusive] Download Jen’s results and response here.
Students Need Time to Plan – Actually All Writers Do
Every year, Jen finds the 5-minute planning time impossible. As she says, ‘I can’t even drink a coffee in five minutes, let alone plan a powerful piece of writing.’
Students need time to brainstorm, come up with an idea that is original – not the first idea that springs to mind. Importantly, they need to plan how they will structure their writing. How will their start sizzle, how will they build tension and end with impact? Fifteen minutes should be the minimum planning time for any piece of sustained writing.
What can you do to help students make the most of their 5 minutes?
NAPLAN is only one test. Great writing needs lots of planning, so keep up your great work on Step 1: Plan for Success. Before NAPLAN next year, practise some fast brainstorming drills and teach kids how to draw the Writing Graph so they can quickly map out their ideas.
[Members’ Exclusive Insights] Explore how much time authors truly spend planning.
Spelling, Grammar, Punctuation Are Given Too Much Weight
The heavy weighting given to these secretarial parts of writing (11/48 marks or nearly 23%) seems unfair. The Language Conventions NAPLAN test already measures this – why double test?
Jen, like most students, ran out of time at the end so couldn’t review and edit her writing. That’s where her points took a hit.
What can you do to help students with this?
We think the perfect time to worry about spelling, grammar and punctuation is when you have a near-final draft. That’s when you should take some time to review your writing to Ban the Boring and clean up your mistakes.
It can be hard to allow time for this though in a test situation. Get students in the habit of doing at least one re-read of their writing – making sure to fix obvious spelling mistakes, add missing punctuation and cutting out unnecessary sentences and words.
[Related Videos] Jen’s big tips on how to practise for NAPLAN
So What Did Jen Score?
Check out Jen’s response to the Years 7/9 writing topic and how she was marked. Did she make Band 10?!
Be sure to share Jen’s writing with your students so they can see how even a published author can’t get a perfect score!
A simple and clear guide on how to teach writing
The path to great NAPLAN results begins now!
It’s not easy to turn an idea into a spectacular piece of writing in 40 minutes. But students are expected to do just that.
Unlock the explicit framework for breaking writing down into Seven (simple) Steps. As a result, your students build their writing skills and celebrate small successes that excite and engage them.
The final product? Students who are confident to write, and a 40-minute writing task that produces amazing results.
More Useful Links
- Article from Education HQ: Award-winning author sits NAPLAN writing test. How does she go?
- NAPLAN and the Seven Steps
- Great practice for NAPLAN: Creativity in the Classroom
- What are the Seven Steps?